OMG! Insane Sale!
Godlike

Better MC BMC4 vs BMC5: Which Version Should Your Server Use?

Fawn

Fawn

Minecraft Writer
  • 13 min read
  • 13 views
  • 0 likes
  • Published:

The choice of BMC4 vs BMC5 depends on several factors, including the Minecraft version and the modpack build installed in your players' launchers.

Make your own FREE minecraft server MINECRAFT FREE SERVER
  • Choose Better MC [FORGE] BMC4 if your community wants Minecraft 1.20.1 on Forge. BMC4 has the largest player base, as proven by 19M+ CurseForge downloads as of November 2026. The largest BMC4 mod list consists of approximately 393 client mods.
  • Choose Better MC [NEOFORGE] BMC5 if your players want Minecraft 1.21.1 features on NeoForge. BMC5 consists of approximately 378 client mods and has 3.09M+ downloads as of November 2026.

BMC5 is a separate modpack built for Minecraft 1.21.1 rather than an update to BMC4. That is why worlds cannot be transferred between BMC4 and BMC5.

BMC4 vs BMC5: What Are the Core Server Differences?

The core server differences in Better MC BMC4 vs BMC5 concern the base game version, the mod loader, and the required Better MC Java version. BMC4 runs on Minecraft 1.20.1 using Forge and Java 17, while BMC5 runs on Minecraft 1.21.1 using NeoForge and Java 21.

Parameter Better MC [FORGE] BMC4 Better MC [NEOFORGE] BMC5
Full name on CurseForge Better MC [FORGE] BMC4 Better MC [NEOFORGE] BMC5
Minecraft version Minecraft 1.20.1 Minecraft 1.21.1
Mod loader Forge (47.3.x+) NeoForge (21.1.x+)
Java version Java 17 Java 21
Latest version (as of November, 2026) v63 HF (Nov 11, 2026) / v63 (Nov 7, 2026) v54 (Oct 29, 2026) / v53 (Sep 8, 2026)
Mods in server pack ~369 server mods (~393 client mods, as of Nov 2026) 351 server mods (~378 client mods, as of Nov 2026)
CurseForge downloads 19M+ (as of Nov 2026) 3.09M+ (as of Nov 2026)
Quests (FTB Quests) Yes — FTB Quests (100+ quests) Yes — FTB Quests, FTB Library, FTB Teams
Server pack file BMC4_ServerPack_v63hf.zip (1023.7 MB) BMC5 ServerPack v53 (632.2 MB); v54 has no server pack yet
Recommended server RAM 6–8 GB of RAM (4 GB minimum)
6 GB is recommended on Godlike
6–8 GB of RAM is recommended (4 GB minimum)
Availability on Godlike Host Yes — One-click installation on Better MC server hosting Yes — One-click installation from the Modpacks tab in the Godlike Panel

Both Better MC [FORGE] BMC4 and Better MC [NEOFORGE] BMC5 are maintained by LunaPixelStudios. This development team offers dedicated Better MC server pack (BMC4 / BMC5) releases and FTB Quests integration. Your choice depends on whether your players prefer Minecraft 1.20.1 Forge mods in BMC4 or Minecraft 1.21.1 Trial Chambers on NeoForge in BMC5.

Is BMC5 the Successor to BMC4?

No, BMC5 is not a sequel or update to BMC4. These Better MC versions are standalone modpacks. BMC4 and BMC5 are designed for different versions of Minecraft and a particular mod loader. The LunaPixelStudios team develops BMC4 and BMC5 in parallel, as two independent projects. The numbers in the names are generation labels, not Minecraft versions: BMC4 runs on 1.20.1 and BMC5 on 1.21.1. They do not indicate that one is a newer version of the other.

Which Better MC Version Should Your Server Run?

The choice of which Better MC version your server should run depends on the priorities of your group:

  • A wide range of mods for Forge in the Better MC [FORGE] BMC4 modpack;
  • Vanilla-style content based on NeoForge in the Better MC [NEOFORGE] BMC5 modpack.

You can deploy both packs in one click: BMC4 on Better MC server hosting and BMC5 from the Modpacks tab in the Godlike Panel. Find out the ranks of BMC4 and BMC5 in our guide to the top 8 best Minecraft modpacks for 2026.

Choose Better MC [FORGE] BMC4 if:

  • Your server runs on Minecraft version 1.20.1. The BMC4 modpack is designed for Minecraft 1.20.1. BMC4 uses Forge 47.3.x and Java 17. BMC4 includes about 393 client-side mods and about 369 server-side mods as of November 2026.
  • Your players have BMC4 installed. As of November 2026, BMC4 has more than 19 million downloads on CurseForge. This makes BMC4 the most popular modpack from LunaPixelStudios.
  • You need mods that are available for Forge 1.20.1. BMC4 includes mods that are not available in the BMC5 version. They run only on Forge 1.20.1. Alex's Mobs and Blue Skies, which add new dimensions and creatures, are among them.
  • You want a stable and well-developed update cycle. By November 2026, BMC4 had reached v63 HF after more than 60 releases. This provides high stability for long-term multiplayer servers (SMP).

Choose Better MC [NEOFORGE] BMC5 if:

  • Your group wants the gameplay mechanics of Minecraft 1.21.1. The BMC5 modpack runs on Minecraft 1.21.1. BMC5 includes vanilla features such as Trial Chambers, the Breeze and Bogged mobs, the Crafter block, and the Mace weapon. The modpack consists of approximately 378 client-side mods and 351 server-side mods as of November 2026.
  • You prefer to use NeoForge 1.21.1 and Java 21. BMC5 is based on NeoForge 21.1.x and Java 21. You can compare different mod loaders in our guide to Minecraft Fabric, Forge, and NeoForge.
  • Your players are starting a new 1.21.1 world. BMC5 has 3.09M+ downloads and 54 releases as of November 2026, with full FTB Quests progression for fresh 1.21.1 survival worlds.
Server type Recommended version Why this specific version is a good choice
A private server for friends Better MC [NEOFORGE] BMC5 (or BMC4) BMC5 allows you to play Minecraft 1.21.1 in co-op mode with FTB Teams. BMC5 requires 6–8 GB of RAM.
Suitable for long-term SMP Better MC [FORGE] BMC4 BMC4 offers about 369 server mods on Minecraft 1.20.1 with more than 60 releases (v63 HF as of November 2026).
Players who already have BMC4 Better MC [FORGE] BMC4 Players can join a BMC4 1.20.1 server without downloading a second pack.
A server with a small amount of RAM (4–5 GB) Better MC [FABRIC] BMC2 or BMC3 BMC4 and BMC5 need 6 GB+ RAM. 4 GB servers run smoother on Fabric editions BMC2 (1.20.1) or BMC3 (1.21.1).
Groups wanting the newest Minecraft Better MC [NEOFORGE] BMC5 (or BMC6) BMC5 runs on Minecraft 1.21.1 (Java 21). Groups wanting Minecraft 26.1.2 can run BMC6 on Java 25.

What's Different in Gameplay Between BMC4 and BMC5?

The primary gameplay difference in BMC4 vs BMC5 is that Better MC [FORGE] BMC4 centers on Minecraft 1.20.1 with a broader Forge dimension roster (~393 client mods). Better MC [NEOFORGE] BMC5 combines Minecraft 1.21.1 Trial Chambers with ~378 NeoForge mods.

For vanilla mechanics, Better MC [FORGE] BMC4 includes Minecraft 1.20.1 features such as archaeology, cherry groves, sniffers, and armor trims. Better MC [NEOFORGE] BMC5 runs on Minecraft 1.21.1 with Tricky Trials. Since BMC5 runs on Minecraft 1.21.1, players on a BMC5 server get the following:

  • Underground Trial Chambers
  • The Breeze and Bogged mobs
  • Ominous Trials
  • The Mace weapon
  • Automated item crafting using the Crafter block

None of this is present in the base version of the BMC4 modpack for Minecraft 1.20.1.

A comparison of the mod lists for BMC4 and BMC5 shows that both packs include:

  • The Aether
  • Aether Villages
  • The Twilight Forest

Better MC [FORGE] BMC4 for version 1.20.1 includes the mods Deep Aether, The Aether: Redux, Blue Skies, and Alex's Mobs. In contrast, Better MC [NEOFORGE] BMC5 omits mods that have not been ported to the new platform, such as Alex's Mobs. BMC5 focuses on world-generation and structure mods designed for NeoForge 1.21.1, such as Biomes O' Plenty, Geophilic, and Friends & Foes.

Despite different loader-specific mods, Better MC [FORGE] BMC4 and Better MC [NEOFORGE] BMC5 share LunaPixelStudios' signature Vanilla+ design. Both BMC4 and BMC5 include overhauled Overworld, Nether, and End biomes, 20+ bosses, dragon mounts, Waystones, Xaero's Minimap, and FTB Quests. Moreover, BMC4 is advertising 100+ quests on CurseForge.

What About BMC6 and the Fabric Versions (BMC2, BMC3)?

Beyond BMC4 and BMC5, the active Better MC versions family from LunaPixelStudios includes a medium-to-large modpack and two lighter Fabric packs:

  • Better MC [BMC6] for Minecraft 26.1.2 on NeoForge
  • Better MC [FABRIC] BMC2 (1.20.1)
  • Better MC [FABRIC] BMC3 (1.21.1)
Version Loader Minecraft Java Status & Scale (as of November 2026)
Better MC [FABRIC] BMC2 Fabric 1.20.1 Java 17 Active
Version: v40
Updated: Jan 24, 2026
List of mods: 280+
Downloads: 2.16M+
Lighter 1.20.1 Fabric alternative to BMC4
Better MC [FABRIC] BMC3 Fabric 1.21.1 Java 21 Active
Version: v45
Updated: May 7, 2026
List of mods: 330+
Downloads: 1.49M+
Better MC [FORGE] BMC4 Forge 1.20.1 Java 17 Active flagship
Version: v63 HF
Updated: Nov 11, 2026
List of mods: ~393
Downloads: 19M+
Better MC [NEOFORGE] BMC5 NeoForge 1.21.1 Java 21 Active flagship
Version: v54
Updated: Oct 2026
List of mods: ~378
Downloads: 3.09M+
Better MC [BMC6] NeoForge 26.1.2 Java 25 Active newest release
Version: v9
Updated: Nov 14, 2026
List of mods: 228
Downloads: 161K+

Better MC [BMC6] runs on Minecraft 26.1.2 with NeoForge and Java 25. BMC6 offers 228 mods for players wanting the newest Minecraft version. BMC6 currently has fewer mods than BMC4 or BMC5 and lacks Aether dimensions. As of November 2026, BMC6 has 161K+ downloads. Better MC [FABRIC] BMC2 and Better MC [FABRIC] BMC3 are independent Fabric modpacks built for lower memory usage with a different mod list than BMC4 or BMC5. BMC4 and BMC5 install in one click: BMC4 on Better MC server hosting and BMC5 from the Modpacks tab in the Godlike Panel. BMC2, BMC3, and BMC6 can be installed on our modded Minecraft server hosting platform via the CurseForge modpack installer in the Godlike Panel or by uploading the server pack.

How Much RAM Does a BMC4 or BMC5 Server Need?

A Better MC [FORGE] BMC4 or Better MC [NEOFORGE] BMC5 server needs at least 4 GB of RAM to start and 6 GB to 8 GB of RAM for smooth multiplayer gameplay. For larger groups, you will need to scale to 10 GB–12 GB+ of RAM.

Concurrent Players Better MC [FORGE] BMC4 Server RAM Better MC [NEOFORGE] BMC5 Server RAM
1–4 Players 6 GB RAM (4 GB minimum) 6 GB RAM (4 GB minimum)
5–10 Players 8 GB RAM 8 GB RAM
11–20 Players 10 GB–12 GB+ RAM 10 GB–12 GB+ RAM

The default BetterMC server pack for both BMC4 and BMC5 sets JVM_ARGS=-Xmx4G in variables.txt. This amount of RAM is too low once multiple players explore modded dimensions simultaneously. Check memory needs with our RAM calculator. For each player's desktop launcher, LunaPixelStudios recommends allocating 8 GB to 10 GB of client RAM for both BMC4 and BMC5.

How Do You Set Up a BMC4 or BMC5 Server?

Setting up Better MC [FORGE] BMC4 or Better MC [NEOFORGE] BMC5 takes one click: BMC4 on Better MC server hosting, BMC5 from the Modpacks tab in the Godlike Panel. You can also upload the official Better MC server pack and run it with the matching Better MC Java version.

Follow this setup on Godlike hosting:

  1. For BMC4 (One-click installation). Select a plan with at least 6 GB of RAM on Better MC server hosting. You will be able to automatically deploy the pre-configured Better MC [FORGE] BMC4 build (Forge 1.20.1, Java 17, 6 GB RAM).
  2. For BMC5 (one-click installation) or BMC6 (CurseForge installer). Choose a 6 GB–8 GB+ modded server plan. For BMC5, open the Modpacks tab in the Godlike Panel, select Better MC [NEOFORGE] BMC5 and click Install. For BMC6, use the CurseForge installer and follow our guide on how to install a custom CurseForge modpack automatically. You can also upload a server pack using SFTP.
  3. Verify Java and start. Open the Startup tab. Confirm that BMC4 runs on Java 17, BMC5 runs on Java 21, and BMC6 runs on Java 25. Accept the EULA and click the Start button.

Godlike plan calculator recommending the Ultra plan with 6 GB RAM for Better MC [FORGE] BMC4 (1.20.1 v63 HF) with 3-4 players

Godlike plan calculator recommending the Ultra plan with 6 GB RAM for Better MC [NEOFORGE] BMC5 (v54) with 3-4 players

If you prefer manual setup, go to the Files section on the CurseForge project page, open the version you need, and download the server archive from Additional Files. For BMC4 v63 HF, this is BMC4_ServerPack_v63hf.zip. BMC5 v54 has no server pack yet: the latest one is BMC5 ServerPack v53, so run v53 on the server and on every client, or install v54 with the CurseForge installer. Don't use the client-side game files.

Install Java 17 for BMC4 or Java 21 for BMC5. In the variables.txt file, change the -Xmx4G parameter to -Xmx6G or -Xmx8G. Run the start.ps1 file for Windows or start.sh file for Linux. Set eula=true in the eula.txt file. See our server hosting page for more details.

Can You Move a BMC4 World to BMC5?

No, it is not possible to transfer a world from the Better MC [FORGE] (BMC4) modpack to Better MC [NEOFORGE] (BMC5). BMC4 and BMC5 use different versions of Minecraft (1.20.1 and 1.21.1), different mod loaders (Forge and NeoForge), and have incompatible block registries. When moving from BMC4 to BMC5, you will need to create a new 1.21.1 world in BMC5. Before doing so, be sure to save a backup of your BMC4 world with the help of the Godlike control panel.

What Are the Most Common Better MC Server Problems and Fixes?

Most server errors in BMC4 vs BMC5 are caused by selecting an incorrect Better MC Java version, failing to remove the 4 GB RAM limit in the variables.txt file, or a version mismatch between the BMC4/BMC5 client and the server.

Problem Cause Fix
Java error at Startup (UnsupportedClassVersionError) Running BMC4 without Java 17, or BMC5 without Java 21. Install Java 17 for BMC4 or Java 21 for BMC5. Use the Startup tab in the Godlike control panel or update the variables.txt file.
Mismatched mod or channel list (mismatched mod channel list) A player is attempting to connect to a BMC5 server using a BMC4 client.
A player is using a different version of the modpack (e.g., BMC4 v63 instead of v63 HF).
Ask all players to run the pack and release versions installed on the server.
OutOfMemoryError: Java heap space or low TPS The Better MC server pack defaults to -Xmx4G in variables.txt. This is too low for multiple players in BMC4 or BMC5. Increase the allocated RAM in the variables.txt file or upgrade your hosting plan on Godlike to 6–8 GB or more.
Crash during mod loading (Error: invalid dist DEDICATED_SERVER) Client-only rendering mods or client profile folders were uploaded instead of the official Better MC server pack. Use the official BMC4 or BMC5 Server Pack from CurseForge Additional Files and remove client-only mods from /mods.
World fails to load after updating BMC4 or BMC5 Updating BMC4 or BMC5 without deleting old /mods and /config folders leaves duplicate .jar files. Back up the world, delete old mods/, config/, defaultconfigs/, and kubejs/ folders. Upload the new server pack folders.

FAQ

  • Is BMC5 better than BMC4?

    None of these modpacks can be called the best, because BMC4 and BMC5 are designed for different versions of Minecraft. Choose BMC4 for Minecraft 1.20.1, Forge compatibility, and around 393 mods. Install BMC5 if you are interested in Minecraft 1.21.1 with Trial Chambers, NeoForge support, and about 378 mods (as of November 2026).
  • Is BMC5 an update to BMC4?

    No, BMC5 is not an update to BMC4. LunaPixelStudios is developing BMC4 for Minecraft 1.20.1 based on Forge and BMC5 for Minecraft 1.21.1 based on NeoForge in parallel. These are separate modpacks. This is why worlds and server files cannot be transferred from BMC4 to BMC5.
  • What Java version do BMC4 / BMC5 need?

    The Better MC Java version depends on the underlying Minecraft version. Better MC [FORGE] BMC4 (Minecraft 1.20.1) requires Java 17. Better MC [NEOFORGE] BMC5 (Minecraft 1.21.1) requires Java 21. If you are running Better MC [BMC6] on Minecraft version 26.1.2, your server will require Java 25.
  • How many mods are in BMC4 and BMC5?

    As of November 2026, the BMC4 mod list for Better MC [FORGE] BMC4 contains approximately 393 client mods and about 369 mods in the Better MC server pack. Better MC [NEOFORGE] BMC5 (v54) contains about 378 client mods and 351 server pack mods as of November 2026.
  • Can BMC4 and BMC5 players join the same server?

    No, players using BMC4 and BMC5 cannot play on the same server. The BMC4 modpack is based on Minecraft 1.20.1 and uses Forge. BMC5 is based on Minecraft 1.21.1 and uses NeoForge. That is why each player must install the version of the modpack that is being used on the server.
  • Does Better MC have quests?

    Yes, both Better MC [FORGE] BMC4 and Better MC [NEOFORGE] BMC5 include guided progression using FTB Quests, FTB Library, and FTB Teams. BMC4 advertises 100+ quests on CurseForge, guiding players through Overworld, Nether, End, The Aether, and Twilight Forest bosses in both BMC4 and BMC5.
  • Can I host BMC5 or BMC6 on Godlike.Host?

    Yes, you can host BMC4, BMC5, and BMC6 at Godlike.Host. Better MC [FORGE] BMC4 and Better MC [NEOFORGE] BMC5 deploy in one click: BMC4 on Better MC server hosting, BMC5 from the Modpacks tab in the Godlike Panel. Install Better MC [BMC6] via the automatic CurseForge modpack installer in the Godlike Panel or by uploading the official server pack.
  • Which Better MC version uses the least RAM?

    BMC2 and BMC3 use less RAM than BMC4 (about 393 mods) or BMC5 (about 378 mods). They run smoothly even with 4–6 GB of RAM on the server.
Fawn

Fawn

Minecraft Writer

Hi, I'm Fawn. I started out just messing around in Minecraft with friends, then one thing led to another, and suddenly I was streaming, building worlds, and losing sleep over redstone logic. I like games that make you feel something—whether it’s a good RPG story like Nier or Kingdom Hearts, or the collective suffering of solo-queuing in Valorant. Mostly, I just create, experiment, and have fun with it :D
×

Report a bug

Error text

Your choice